jnl:ghanem2016
Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision | ||
|
jnl:ghanem2016 [2019/05/02 08:07] admin |
jnl:ghanem2016 [2020/05/15 05:43] (current) admin [Commentary] |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
| {{: | {{: | ||
| + | {{: | ||
| ====Commentary==== | ====Commentary==== | ||
| ===Key=== | ===Key=== | ||
| * Good: low-fi, can differentiate expert/ | * Good: low-fi, can differentiate expert/ | ||
| * Bad: manual ? inter-rater?; | * Bad: manual ? inter-rater?; | ||
| + | * need an expert to do it | ||
| ===Assessment Model=== | ===Assessment Model=== | ||
| * Outcome only | * Outcome only | ||
| + | * Assessor score. Bias, rating, score - [[ac: | ||
| + | * Weighting - each error given equal weight -- is that really the case? see [[bk: | ||
| + | * Experts: also made errors (between 2-2.5 errors); do they make different errors? | ||
| * Size of rat aorta? | * Size of rat aorta? | ||
| * Can differentiate expert, but how does it correlate with patency? | * Can differentiate expert, but how does it correlate with patency? | ||
| ===Methodology=== | ===Methodology=== | ||
| - | * 29 participants with 1 anastomosis each on day 3 and day 5; 2 experts with 3 anastomosis on D3 and 1 on D4 | + | * 29 participants with 2 anastomosis each on day 3 and day 5; 2 experts with 3 anastomosis on D1 and 3 on D3 |
| * " | * " | ||
| * SD for expert group higher (2.5) vs (1.0-1.3) for other groups --> there is some variability anastomosis to anastomosis | * SD for expert group higher (2.5) vs (1.0-1.3) for other groups --> there is some variability anastomosis to anastomosis | ||
| Line 34: | Line 39: | ||
| ===Discussion=== | ===Discussion=== | ||
| - | The authors quote Kaufman (whom I assume takes from Fitts-Posner), | + | The authors quote [[jnl: |
| ===So What?=== | ===So What?=== | ||
jnl/ghanem2016.1556784439.txt.gz ยท Last modified: 2020/03/24 02:34 (external edit)
Page Tools
